Queer Weddings: Grammy 2014

By: Lisa Leitz

During the January 26, 2014 Grammy Awards Queen Latifah presided over 33 couples that wed during Macklemore, Ryan Lewis, and Mary Lambert’s “Same Love” mashup with Madonna’s “Open Your Heart.” Recent posts have critiqued the heteronormativity in both CBS news coverage and the Grammy focus on the straight stars in the event and its de-politicization of the song.

While others have analyzed the political message of the song to conclude it as barely more than straight “rappers” heralding the assimilationist agenda of HRC, I look around my current rural state of Arkansas and can’t help but wonder- can we understand the Grammy Weddings to be a political tactic or are they merely feeding the pocketbooks of already-mega-rich pop stars?

One answer lies in outcomes, which we have so much difficulty measuring as social movement scholars. Changes in attitudes toward same-sex weddings would be hard to trace (in the aggregate) to one event like this. We need to continue to develop methods for systematically analyzing social media and audiences (like marketing pros use) to better get at researching the success of tactics.

Another answer seems to lie in what we believe to be an acceptable outcome of a tactic like this- queering our notions of marriage or simply marriage equality, and that gets at a fundamental divide, not just in the queer community but throughout organizing and social movement scholarship, about radical vs. mainstream organizing. Are only radical politics/tactics worthwhile? Do tactics that push toward the middle also aid the margins? And if so to what end? Sure marriage has real consequences for those in the LGBTQIA community who can obtain them, but in the end are we only reifying a structure that marginalizes those in other types of families & genders? Here we need long-term outcome studies that help us understand when and how radical and more mainstream social movement tactics work, separately and in tandem. Some of this work was started in Bernstein & Taylor’s The Marrying Kind, but clearly more is needed.

While the critiques of the “Same Love” lyrics, as well as the music and television industries’ “add gays and stir” attitude toward LGBTQIA issues is  warranted, I can’t help but think that given the political realities of America (and its pop culture, if we are to be honest with ourselves) watered down messages like this have a place in trying to reach people where they are at. Macklemore shouldn’t be heralded as an edgy activist but as a savvy political framer, whose words can reach a wider audience than most radical critics could dream. Yes, his message offers a soft and sweet version of same-sex love that a wide variety of people can relate to, therefore leaving many  problematic assumptions of gender and sexuality unchallenged. However, if his music is played even in conservative communities, doesn’t it have real consequences? Not all live in the more-queer-friendly spaces of academia, New York City, or Southern California, from which many of the critiques came. Had Macklemore, Lewis, and Lambert sung a song that challenged too much of mainstream culture, it probably wouldn’t have saturated the airwaves or the awards. A wide variety of tactics, many of them imperfect, are necessary for change.

4 Comments

Filed under Daily Disruption

4 responses to “Queer Weddings: Grammy 2014

  1. Tonya Hale

    Fantastic post and I wholeheartedly agree. The conversation gets even more complicated when you consider the complications that come from him being a white man that has had so much success in a predominantly African-American genre (hip-hop). The question of “ownership” comes to mind on all fronts – do only LGBTQ people “own” the fight for equal rights and do only African-Americans “own” hip-hop. You’ll get many different answers across the board.

  2. Loved the post, Cousin! I think it is something good to talk about. Like you said, I think it is important to think about the performance into the perspective of it going into small communities all around the US that normally would never witness as LGBT wedding, so in that respect I think it is progress. I had a couple LGBT friends here in NY who didn’t feel it was radical enough and that the moment was less special because many of the cameras focused on straight couples. Although I do understand their disappointment, I think any progress in showing greater human acceptance on large media outlets is better than nothing.

    Also, from a musician’s standpoint, I would say there was a pretty decent chance that when they wrote that song, they had no idea it would have blown up in the way that it did or be used as some type of political anthem. Most controversial topic songs barely make it on the album, let alone actually making it to the radio and especially not the Grammys. I personally was kind of shocked (happy shocked because I love the song) when I heard it on the radio in Northern Michigan. But this brings me back to your point that I think with songs like “Same Love” you have to focus less on being radical or pushing the envelope for the more liberal areas of the US and focus on the change and acceptance it could have for those who aren’t exposed to it daily.

  3. Kent Denton

    I am so happy to have taken a class under the awesome Lisa Leitz. This is so spot on it makes me want to make my husband read it! And he hates reading! While I certainly don’t plan to settle for baby steps forever; it is important in many parts of the country to meet people where they are to even begin a dialogue about the Queer community. I applaud and appreciate you. Thanks for putting so eloquently what I tend to yell at people.😉

  4. Pingback: Google doodle draws attention to gay rights and the 2014 Olympics | Mobilizing Ideas

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s