Civilian Deaths and Radicalism

As we are involved in a heated debate about Obama’s kill list and controversial drone attacks in Pakistan, it is timely to ask whether American public sufficiently comprehends seriousness of the issue of civilian deaths, which poses a great danger in fighting against terrorist networks and radical movements. In his new book, The Deaths of Others: The Fate of Civilians in America’s Wars (Oxford University Press, 2011), John Tirman presents a compelling argument to explain why a culture of public “indifference” still dominates.

According to Tirman, there are three major reasons behind this lack of public attention: racism (i.e. Americans’ lives are more important than some other people’s lives), frontier myth (i.e. a strong belief in USA’s mission in world politics), and psychological aversion (i.e. just too much burden for someone to think about these disturbing issues). Examining Korean War, Vietnam War, and recent wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, Tirman also indicates how American public were made in dark, and thus, were deceived about number of civilian deaths. At the outset of the Iraqi war,  only 73 of 18000 news stories on the major networks mentioned Iraqi casualties. By 2008, during the time American public supported to pull out of the country, any coverage of the Iraq war went down to 3 per cent (

It is interesting to read Tirman at a time the BBC is facing criticism due to its use of a photo taken in Iraq in 2003 to illustrate massacre of children in Syria (see the photo). The issue of civilian deaths, for sure, is quite significant to understand anti-American radicalism in Muslim-populated regions. American public indifference would only further help radical movements, which are dramatically gaining grassroots support as civilian deaths increase.



Filed under Daily Disruption

2 responses to “Civilian Deaths and Radicalism

  1. Jeff Goodwin

    Another reason for lack of public attention to state terrorism by the U.S. government (let’s call a spade a spade) is sheer ignorance. The corporate media do a horrible job informing the public about it. I meet politically sophisticated people all the time who are unaware that more Iraqi civilians were probably killed by our economic sanctions during the 1990s than by the U.S. invasion and occupation–well over half a million preventable deaths. The whole sordid story is related in an excellent book by Joy Gordon, Invisible War (Harvard University Press, 2010).


  2. Pingback: On Tribalism-Radicalism Nexus | Mobilizing Ideas

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s